Should Americans Wear Masks for COVID-19? | The Institute for Creation Research

Should Americans Wear Masks for COVID-19?
Watching COVID-19 news reporting on South Koreans and Americans shows one stark difference: South Koreans are wearing some kind of face mask but Americans are not. Should Americans be wearing a face mask? The CDC is reconsidering the issue, and a report on several studies on this topic was just published today in the British science journal Nature.1 Readers of ICR news should be aware of these, because the studies could influence their decisions if they want to voluntarily wear a mask outside their homes.

The report could not give a definitive answer because it is remarkably hard to gather good quality data. The studies take time to complete, and there are disagreements in the scientific community over critical details. Important questions that need to be answered are: Can the virus be spread through the air? If so, how far can the virus particles travel? How long do virus particles remain infectious after leaving an infected person? How many virus particles must contaminate a non-infected person to be considered a viable infectious dose? The dilemma is that to get a definitive answer will take time—and that time lag could result in additional, possibly preventable, infections.

Much of the discussion to make a public recommendation rests on a key distinction described in the report:

When public health officials say there isn't sufficient evidence to say that COVID-19 is airborne, they specifically mean transported in virus-laden aerosols smaller than 5 micrometres in diameter. Compared with droplets, which are heftier and thought to travel only short distances after someone coughs or sneezes before falling to the floor or onto other surfaces, aerosols can linger in the air for longer and travel further.

The report mentioned several studies which seemed to show definite evidence that virus particles are aerosolized and could linger in the air. This means that they could infect a person farther away than the six-foot social-distancing guideline. At least one other study in the report had equivocal findings.

Given these realities, should Americans be advised to wear masks? The report notes,

The Czech Republic and Slovakia, however, have made it mandatory for people to wear masks outside the home. Tang [virologist Julian Tang at the University of Leicester, UK] thinks those countries have taken the right approach. “They are following the southeast Asia approach. If everyone can mask, it is double, two-way protection,” he says.

Two other comments in the report are worth taking into consideration as citizens and the CDC evaluate the benefit of wearing a face mask:

But experts that work on airborne respiratory illnesses and aerosols say that gathering unequivocal evidence for airborne transmission could take years and cost lives. We shouldn’t “let perfect be the enemy of convincing”, says Michael Osterholm, an infectious-disease epidemiologist at the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis.

And,

“In the mind of scientists working on this, there’s absolutely no doubt that the virus spreads in the air,” says aerosol scientist Lidia Morawska at the Queensland University of Technology in Brisbane, Australia. “This is a no-brainer.”

South Koreans began wearing face masks immediately upon national exposure to the virus that causes COVID-19. How much of their successful containment efforts can be attributed to that action alone is unknown. Perhaps if the CDC recommended that Americans start wearing masks, then we could collect epidemiological data from large U.S. cities that could be compared to New York City where people were not wearing masks. When people ask me personally if I wear a mask, I’m in the same camp as Lidia Morawska. My answer is “Yes.”

References
1. Lewis, D. 2020. Is the coronavirus airborne? Experts can’t agree. Posted on nature.com April 2, 2020, accessed April 2, 2020. doi: 10.1038/d41586-020-00974-w

*Randy Guliuzza is ICR’s National Representative. He earned his Doctor of Medicine from the University of Minnesota, his Master of Public Health from Harvard University, and served in the U.S. Air Force as 28th Bomb Wing Flight Surgeon and Chief of Aerospace Medicine. Dr. Guliuzza is also a registered Professional Engineer.
The Latest
NEWS
A ''40 million year old'' 100% European Gnat
Finding well-preserved creatures in amber1 is a landfall for creation scientists, much like the numerous discoveries of soft dinosaur tissue...

CREATION PODCAST
The Undeniable Power of Narrative | The Creation Podcast: Episode...
Science is objective. At least, that’s what we’re told. But there are inherent issues with this statement that can cause...

NEWS
Paintbrush of the Creator
Who doesn’t enjoy the amazing color patterns of butterflies?1,2 Such beautiful designs and construction do not reflect blind naturalistic...

NEWS
November 2024 ICR Wallpaper
"Rejoice always, pray without ceasing, in everything give thanks; for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus for you." (1 Thessalonians 5:16-18 NKJV) ICR...

NEWS
Reformation Day, October 31
Five hundred years ago in Wittenberg, Germany, an unusual scholar changed the course of human history using pen and hammer. Dr. Martin Luther protested...

ACTS & FACTS
Creation Kids: Owls
by Sydney Walters and Susan Windsor* You're never too young to be a creation scientist and explore our Creator's world. Kids, discover...

ACTS & FACTS
RNA Hoops: When Circular Reasoning Makes Sense
If the regulatory picture of the genome were not complicated enough, over the past decade scientists have discovered another level of Darwinian-defying...

ACTS & FACTS
Gunnison National Forest: Adaptable Aspens and Warped Rocks
Gunnison National Forest’s 1.67-millionplus acres showcase stunning views of the Colorado Rocky Mountains. The Continental Divide forms its eastern...

ACTS & FACTS
Applying the Theory of Biological Design to Optimal Owl Flight
by Randy J. Guliuzza, P.E., M.D., and Aaron T. Guliuzza, P.E.*   If the greatest writers had been well-versed in fields of science,...

ACTS & FACTS
The Jaw-Dropping Design in Hawaii's State Fish
Hawaiians call their state fish the humuhumunukunukuapua’a, or humuhumu for short, and snorkelers marvel at its wild paint job as it flits...